Law, State, and Religious Authority

A thoughtful look at how Charedim relate to secular law, the Israeli government, the court system, and the concept of Dina D’malchusa Dina. This section also discusses participation in elections and political roles within a secular state.

What Is the Charedi View on Voting in Israeli Elections?

At first glance, it may seem contradictory: the Charedi community often voices strong opposition to the ideology behind the secular State, yet it turns out to vote in high numbers. Why? The answer lies in the distinction between participating in a system and endorsing it.

Is living under a secular Jewish government better or worse than being under a non-Jewish one?

On the surface, it may seem obvious: Of course it’s better to live under Jewish rule than under a foreign one. After all, aren’t Jews our brothers? Wouldn’t a Jewish government understand our customs, speak our language, and allow us to live more freely as Torah Jews?

What’s the Torah’s View on Liberalism?

"Liberal values" — as used in the modern West — include things like freedom of expression, tolerance, gender equality, personal autonomy, and non-judgmentalism. These ideals sound noble. But Torah Judaism does not judge ideals based on feelings or trends. It judges based on emes.

What is the Torah’s view on democracy?

Democracy, as we know it today — a government chosen by the people, based on majority rule — is not a concept found in the Torah.

What is the Chareidi View of the State of Israel’s Government — Is It Considered a Legitimate Authority?

From a Torah standpoint, legitimate rule over the Jewish People requires a foundation in Torah. As the Torah states in Devarim 17:15, a king must be chosen by Hashem, through a navi, and accepted by the people.